Zoom Logo

STW5_Literature Review Workshop - Shared screen with speaker view
Yuxin Ni
22:08
1. narrative review
Khaoula Bessame
22:24
1. narrative review
GIFTY - NMU
22:35
Systematic
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
22:39
1. narrative
Takhona Hlatshwako
22:40
2. Systematic review
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
22:41
agree
Xumeng Yan
22:41
2. Systematic review
SESH Global LLC
22:48
2. Systematic review
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
22:51
2. systematic review
Susan
23:05
2 Systematic
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
26:23
http://prisma-statement.org/prismastatement/Checklist.aspx
Takhona Hlatshwako
26:27
How important is it to have a reproducible methodology for a narrative review if the goal is to publish?
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
27:08
scoping review checklist: http://www.prisma-statement.org/Extensions/ScopingReviews
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
27:12
great point about checklists
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
28:05
narrative review has no checklists
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
28:08
least rigor
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
28:43
wow, didn't realize it
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
28:44
https://researchintegrityjournal.biomedcentral.com/articles/10.1186/s41073-019-0064-8
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
28:50
narrative review checklist
Takhona Hlatshwako
29:16
Thanks!
Yuxin Ni
32:32
How many types of digital interventions for PrEP uptake among xxx?
Khaoula Bessame
32:43
what about these interventions do we want to explore? types , effectiveness, ?
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
36:10
WHO loves PICO
Yuxin Ni
38:18
B
Khaoula Bessame
38:46
B
Qianyun
38:53
b
SESH Global LLC
39:00
B
Yuxin Ni
42:39
Where
Takhona Hlatshwako
42:40
Where
Khaoula Bessame
42:41
where
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
58:03
Great talk, Suzanne!
SESH Global LLC
58:04
May be Suzanne can share the slides with us after the meeting
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
58:13
Cochrane is the Bible: https://www.cochranelibrary.com/
Qianyun
58:25
Are we supposed to evaluate the quality of literature before conducting the review?
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
58:51
@Qiayun - definitely for systematic review, maybe for scoping, not for narrative
Qianyun
59:46
Thanks Joe. Any methods?
SESH Global LLC
59:58
GRADE
Khaoula Bessame
59:59
Thank you so much Suzanne, this was very useful!
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
01:00:05
https://casp-uk.net/casp-tools-checklists/
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
01:00:35
CASP is for individual studies; GRADE is for study findings
Jie Fan
01:00:41
Great sharing!Thank you,Dr. Suzanne.
Khaoula Bessame
01:01:12
AMSTAR for systematic reviews, The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials
Qianyun
01:01:29
Thank you! Very appreciated
Susan
01:03:25
Thanks so much - very helpful!
Takhona Hlatshwako
01:03:47
Thank you Suzanne!
Khaoula Bessame
01:03:49
is it worth doing a thorough search for a narrative review (background write-up) for the thesis
Yongjie Sha
01:03:53
Thanks Suzanne!
Khaoula Bessame
01:03:57
ie. using mesh words, truncation
GIFTY - NMU
01:03:57
Thank you
Kay Youngstrom
01:04:00
Thanks Suzanne!
SESH Global LLC
01:04:13
Thanks Suzanne!Great presentation
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
01:05:41
love that
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
01:05:45
"the best is the finished"
Joe Tucker (he/him/his)
01:05:47
hehe
Yuxin Ni
01:06:07
Thank you!
Khaoula Bessame
01:06:10
Thank you!!
Chenqi Jin
01:06:11
Thanks so much Suzanne!
Tong Wang
01:06:12
Thank you!
Fong Yi Fanny Tang
01:06:18
Thank you Suzanne!
Fengshi JING Robert
01:06:22
Thanks!
Dan Wu
01:06:22
thx!
Jie Fan
01:06:23
Thank you
Qianyun
01:06:27
Thank you!
Shufang
01:06:36
Thank you