Let Me Tell You My Idea About That! Empowering Students’ to Make Their Thinking Visible (B), 4/8/2020
- Shared screen with speaker view

01:06:54
Hello Everyone I'm from Gold Coast Australia

01:06:57
Joining from Yokohama Japan

01:07:08
Hello from NH

01:07:26
Hello from Houston, TX

01:07:29
:) From WA

01:07:31
Hello, from Houston, TX

01:07:38
From Terre Haute Indiana

01:07:40
Hello from Austin, TX

01:08:13
From Greencastle, Indiana

01:09:29
From Cincinnati, Ohio

01:09:37
a

01:09:40
A & B

01:09:48
A. I teach elementary students.

01:09:55
I am a Preschool Teacher at a daycare that also has elementary after school students so A.

01:10:01
A am a preservice teacher

01:10:20
I would select D if Early Childhood was reflected

01:10:25
D. Preservice Teacher: Special Education

01:10:53
Preservice

01:12:55
Its web seminar in this series can be found here https://zoom.us/rec/share/9MhxBJvNrmVLQKvW1mqGYKknHZWmX6a8gSMYr_IPnUt1IhH-t75XA-Ub4MkNuvZu?startTime=1585756819000

01:14:01
Collection: https://learningcenter.nsta.org/mylibrary/collection.aspx?id=RysMO9N9i8M_E

01:14:04
Are the three dimensions of learning replacing the 5E's of learning science?

01:14:19
This handout is number 2 in the collection

01:14:25
Do you mean engage, explore etc?

01:14:57
3 dimensions and 5E’s are different ideas but play nicely together.

01:15:20
Dimensions about what students are doing and E’s about how a lesson is structured.

01:15:23
If so, the 3Ds do not replace the 5Es but you use the 3 dimensions to teach with the 5

01:17:20
models are developed to try and predict things

01:17:39
Maxine— we are actually going to model a 5E activity that has been modified to include 3D and phenomena. 5E is still a great framework for this contemporary research advocating for 3D and phenomena-driven science meaning it can happen within the 5Es.

01:18:54
So which model is more suitable for non-STEM programs?

01:19:06
What are some common barriers to creating this classroom culture?

01:19:47
Does one lesson need to include all three or a unit needs to include all 3?

01:21:44
Thank you!

01:22:05
Thank You!

01:23:58
using books to engage students is a worthwhile activity

01:24:10
Maxine— we are adding thee whole lesson to the collection- the 5E one I talked about. But please note the changes Kate makes here in the web seminar to add the contemporary thinking about phenomena and 3D

01:26:43
Yes, I love to see cross curriculum - reading incorporated in the science lesson in elementary school.

01:26:54
Sesame Street!!!

01:27:54
Embedding iteracy into the 5E while addressing the principles of NGSS

01:27:59
https://learningcenter.nsta.org/resource/?id=10.2505/4/sc17_055_03_80

01:28:47
are the links to the video provided?

01:28:58
they are in the slides

01:29:04
Yes Mr. Glenn— they are in the collection too

01:29:05
Links are in the collection here: https://learningcenter.nsta.org/mylibrary/collection.aspx?id=RysMO9N9i8M_E

01:29:08
They are in the resources collection

01:29:13
Hearing through one's feet!

01:29:18
why did she take her shoes off?

01:29:19
Do sounds make vibrations?

01:29:22
Why did she take her shoes off?

01:29:24
Taking her shoes off

01:29:28
Overcoming obstacles

01:29:29
Instruments are different

01:29:31
why did she take her shoes off?

01:29:33
Can she feel the different pitches of the xylophone? or are all the vibrations the same for each note?

01:29:35
how is she able to play

01:29:37
How could she play so beautifully if she's deaf?

01:29:38
I noticed she took her shoes off? Can she feel the sounds?

01:29:38
stick hits something and sound is made

01:29:42
Can she feel the music?

01:29:49
Her shoes coming off so she can hear the music

01:29:50
How can she tell where she is in the music through the vibrations?

01:29:51
That she seems to feel the ground move under feet?

01:30:06
vibrations!!

01:30:16
She takes her shoes off to feel the vibrations in the ground

01:30:28
Sounds made are very fast and repeat

01:30:35
what does reading lips mean? what does being deaf mean?

01:30:42
through vibrations!

01:30:46
Feels vibrations

01:30:48
vibrations

01:30:48
how is that so that she is so emotional/expressive and hear the band?

01:30:48
Would student actually believe that their feet can feel vibrations?

01:30:49
vibrations

01:30:52
Vibrations

01:30:53
Feeling vibrations

01:30:55
vibrations

01:30:57
She hears herself by feeling the movement of the sound.

01:30:58
Sound waves

01:31:01
can feel sound

01:31:02
buzzing

01:31:02
Sound waves

01:31:03
I noticed she paused before playing,

01:31:04
When does she know to come in?

01:31:05
sound waves make vibrations

01:31:05
I agree that she can sense the sound waves.

01:31:07
energy is traveling from one material to another

01:31:07
Energy transferred into movement that travels

01:31:08
Vibrations must be involved but do the vibrations of different pitches fell different?

01:31:08
Sound waves

01:31:12
Sound waves must create physical pulses in the air

01:31:17
moving air around me

01:31:21
She watches the other performers in the group

01:31:21
She can feel the movement of the music

01:31:25
She hears by the feel of the music.

01:31:27
different sounds have different waves

01:31:27
small movements

01:31:28
Her feet moves a bit

01:31:30
Vibrations are something in the air that I feel on my skin.

01:31:35
different wavelengths

01:31:43
Put rice on the drum so kids can visualize how drum head moves.

01:31:49
I know swimmers have special headphones that let them hear in the water. They fit onto the bony part of your head, not over your ears.

01:31:54
She has a sixth sense that enables her to sense the movement of sound waves

01:31:57
I think that the motion also is different for different instruments.

01:32:20
She may not actually be able to hear, but can feel the movement affecting her surroundings and can watch someone giving her cues like the conductor.

01:33:51
I have to go work with my students now. I will finish watching this lesson later. Thanks.

01:34:16
Lines moving down from the drum through its stand to the ground then to her feet

01:34:21
feet

01:34:22
the instrument

01:34:22
source of sound

01:34:25
feet

01:34:25
Feet and sound wave lines

01:34:26
feet and drums

01:34:28
feet, drum stand, floor

01:34:28
sound

01:34:29
feet, movement of the music, instruments

01:34:29
It wasn't just her feel - Instead of just hearing in her ears her whole body can feel it

01:34:32
drum with squiggly lines to her feet

01:34:32
drums

01:34:34
music

01:34:35
The drum, the stick, the “waves” and her feet

01:34:37
vibrations

01:34:40
feet, symbols, waving line

01:34:40
Sound waves going from drum to feet

01:34:40
drum, ground, feet

01:34:45
the waves and her feet feeling it

01:34:45
the sound being made from the drums

01:34:45
the instrument, her feet and vibrations traveling

01:34:46
Drums and feet

01:34:50
sound wave lines (representing sounds), drums, feet

01:34:51
vibrations

01:34:52
arrows showing travel

01:34:53
sound waves moving from the instrument to the feet

01:34:54
where the sound was coming from and arrows to her feet

01:34:55
vibrations

01:34:56
feet

01:34:59
dots

01:35:04
sound moving through the air and through her feet

01:35:10
Instrument, sound waves, feet, arms

01:35:11
drumsticks moving up an down

01:35:18
pulsing/pressure

01:35:23
The physical parts of the drum from top to bottom, floor, foot on floor - the series of material items that connect had to be in my picture. THEN a pulse pattern overlayed.

01:35:34
Im thinking about the nerves and feet working is corelation

01:35:38
Air is a medium by which air travels

01:35:47
space

01:35:47
you feel vibrations

01:35:49
sound travels, ooopppss

01:37:42
nice sound stations. Reggio Emilia had a sound steps set up too.

01:41:23
curved lines for vibrations

01:41:24
curved lines coming from the sound source

01:41:26
the curved lines

01:41:28
that it travels

01:41:29
Spreading outward

01:41:33
sound spreads out

01:41:34
Curved lines moving from the item outward

01:41:43
love the ear pointed toward the sounds

01:41:44
The curved lines represent sound and as they travel they spread out

01:41:46
The sounds is represented by the curved lines, moving away .

01:41:47
sound waves demonstrated by the curved lines

01:41:50
Sound is represented by the curved lines are coming from the source out and then it is received by the boy.

01:41:53
The curved lines get larger and larger, so the area the sound covers increases.

01:41:55
The girl

01:41:56
red is louder

01:42:00
girl

01:42:06
the wider the curve, the louder the sound

01:42:10
Her lines are larger, goes out further.

01:42:11
its going up as scales

01:42:12
The girl

01:42:13
the girl

01:42:18
The sounds are coming from the bird, dog and girl and also the boy is hearing the sounds coming from around him

01:42:55
the space between each pulse is of different size

01:43:51
does the sound go on forever?

01:44:47
Question break coming up— do you have a question?

01:45:37
Is it better to have students draw their ideas individually or as a group?

01:46:23
I would start individually to see what each students thinks and as they move in groups have them come up with a group model.

01:46:31
Stations for doing science, making and revising a model

01:46:51
1. Drawing explanations, 2. Experimentation 3. Building Model over time

01:46:51
Students were changing their design/model based on what they learned

01:46:53
I love that the students try out the different sound making items in centers. Shift 2

01:46:54
Shift 2- Developing and revising a model.

01:46:57
Shift 2 - the station activities, and their modeling

01:47:03
In a looped classroom we explore the same content in deeper ways each year.

01:47:12
Yes I liked the stations that allowed the students do develop their original understanding / diagram

01:47:14
Shift 2- they made a model and did stations

01:47:15
Shift 3 I changed my mind about what I new

01:47:20
learning over time...alone zone, small group and large group

01:47:25
shift 2 - students used patterns in the data to gain understanding of sound and vibrations

01:47:31
I feel like the evidence for shift three is that I feel completely reasonable using this lesson almost unaltered with 6th graders-our models would just have more details and deeper explanations

01:47:36
shift 2- stations of activities and having the children model

01:47:49
Students were trying to figure out and explain how the percussionist could “hear” what she was playing. They drew a model to explain and figured out what was in the system that were included in the phenomenon.

01:48:01
Shift 3 drawing a model, revising the models, and “doing science” coming up with new ideas about sound energy

01:48:16
Shift 2: Practice: stations; Questions: Book: Patterns & differences; dispel the Misconceptions

01:48:21
Shift 3: We were able to first share our original notices and wonders, we then moved through our understanding of sound. Through questioning and coming back to our models and extending our understanding by working with it.

01:48:28
shift 3 asking if they would change their thinking

01:48:47
Shift 2 evidence is activities done in class or they could create as project

01:50:15
shift 3 students show models that prove their thinking and how they progress through the thinking

01:54:58
inquiry based learning that is student lead with the teacher as the facilitator

01:56:20
relate the learning to life experience

01:56:28
is the large group the whole group?

01:56:39
Is there a site where teachers share phenomenon that work particularly well to lead to questions we hope to inspire?

01:56:39
This is great! So true

01:56:45
Heidi, yes the large group is the whole class

01:56:50
kids can be hesitant to share in front of all their peers at once

01:57:25
Laurel there are several. If you do a google search for NGSS Phenomena, you can find several phenomenon banks

01:58:03
Great, thank you.

01:58:24
https://learningcenter.nsta.org/resource/?id=10.2505/4/ss18_041_06_45 How to Turn Any Unit Into a Phenomena Based Student driven Investigation

01:58:25
Meg, start with the lessons here https://www.nextgenscience.org/resources/examples-quality-ngss-design Even if you don't use the lessons you can see/take phenomenon from them. The best teachers are good thieves :)

01:58:52
;)

01:59:03
Thank you!

02:01:02
https://sites.google.com/site/sciencephenomena/

02:01:29
https://www.ngssphenomena.com/

02:01:40
a

02:01:50
A

02:01:54
A

02:02:05
A

02:02:12
A

02:02:24
A

02:02:33
A

02:02:36
A

02:02:48
A

02:03:15
A

02:04:58
For me, data is used to build evidence, therefore, data is the smaller circle. I gather data as evidence

02:05:07
Is data defined with number values?

02:05:37
nah data isn't always numerical

02:06:09
Data can be quantitative or qualitative

02:06:23
Aish, yes!

02:06:57
Qualitative data is generally ranked to give it a number for statistical purposes. Like ranking disturbance on a bird colony.

02:07:03
One supports the other, each dynamic

02:07:09
Your claim needs evidence, but you need reasoning to make the connections

02:07:13
It starts with reasoning then evidence and then creating a claim.

02:07:15
Evidence comes before the claim or informs the claim

02:07:16
Reasoning and evidence goes back to their claim

02:07:21
A claim needs to be sustained by evidence, using reasoning

02:07:21
You need evidence to support your reasoning to explain your claim

02:07:23
They are separate

02:07:25
how does this help first graders

02:07:26
they are coherent

02:07:29
but connected

02:07:29
Reasoning needs to take place

02:07:30
find evidence first to decide on claim

02:07:31
The arrow between claim and evidence is multicolored meaning they are related.

02:07:36
Colors bleed into the next box.

02:07:36
the student has to have evidence first, and reasoning , before the claim

02:07:55
All of these terms could be used with first graders if you explain the words meaning

02:08:07
CER goes with the E in the KLEWS chart?

02:08:21
In a lab, the evidence (results) comes after the claim.

02:08:30
Susette, I never thought of it that way, but yes

02:08:44
I agree with KLEWS

02:08:50
The KLEWS chart supports students in constructing an explanation

02:09:02
defined as a systematic investigation of phenomena by gathering quantifiable data

02:09:36
If you are calling a claim a hypothesis than yes it comes before the experiment, but is a claim testable and falsifiable.

02:10:00
A claim is a statement that you may prove or disprove with evidence

02:10:22
CER used with 5th grade and higher?

02:11:03
Isn’t a CER the same as the L, E, and S on the KLEWS chart?

02:11:51
The mass came from the water.

02:11:53
A claim is the answer to your question that is backed by evidence.

02:11:56
From the Framework, students need to experience a phenomenon (can be big that anchors and unit, or smaller that students figure out over a course of a couple of days) to be able to make a hypothesis - they need data (observations) to create a hypothesis that explains their observations

02:12:04
gathering numerical data and generalizing it to explain a particular phenomenon

02:12:23
The mass came from the water and carbon dioxide with the energy from the light.

02:13:35
A pattern you observe is _____

02:13:43
A pattern that I observe is the radishes wilt when . . .

02:13:51
A pattern I observe is that plants grow with water, but not without water.

02:13:56
a pattern you observed.

02:13:57
A pattern I observe is biomass increases in the presence of water

02:13:59
Why does the no light but water not have as much mass as the middle one

02:13:59
A pattern I observe is biomass is high when water and light are available.

02:14:00
with no light and water

02:14:02
This happens because energy is not created or destroyed.

02:14:13
A pattern I observe is the plants grow with light and water

02:14:14
A pattern that I observed _________ is that water must have weight/mass.

02:14:16
A pattern I observe is that mass increases with components needed for photosynthesis

02:14:25
A pattern I observe is light increases weight, but no mass

02:14:32
A pattern you observe is the mass decreases when there is light but no water.

02:14:32
What causes the mass to decrease when there is no light but there is water?

02:14:32
A pattern I observe is water is need for growth but no light

02:14:33
A pattern that I observed is that they weigh the most with light and water

02:14:38
A pattern I observe is water is needed for growth.

02:14:38
A pattern I observe mass changes

02:14:40
A pattern I observe is that radish seeds are greener and have more mass when there is light and water

02:14:41
A pattern I observe is that the mass decreased without water and without light

02:14:43
A pattern you observe _____________ water must be present for growth.

02:14:44
A pattern I observe is the mass was less than the starting mass on all the seeds except the light and water.

02:14:45
I observe the plants will grow with out light but must have water.

02:14:48
A pattern that I observe is that the seeds without light do not have as much mass as the ones with mass.

02:14:52
a pattern I observe is plants thrive with light and water

02:14:55
Under the conditions of light and water the biomass increases, but without light (regardless of the presence of watter) the biomass decreases.

02:15:06
light is the most important factor for the mass increase, next is water.

02:15:08
A pattern the biomas change even though it got neither light or wtar

02:15:20
The pattern I observed is … plants wilt without either water, or light

02:15:42
Photosynthesis

02:16:13
don't we need a control that got neither light nor water?

02:17:04
The control is no light or water

02:17:16
Heather, I think the control is light and water

02:17:22
Qualitative model-based reasoning technique

02:17:43
transpiration is why it loses so much mass? how the heck it germinates in the first place though...

02:17:57
@Heather, what happens when I take away water? what happens when I take away light?

02:18:19
Did the students create their own experiments to further the investigation?

02:18:37
But I'm still super curious about he mass? I want to see it stay the same lol

02:18:42
It's the same as a hydroponics system set-up short term.

02:19:07
No, Trish strategically used an investigation she taught prior to the NGSS. The phenomenon created a NEED to engage with the investigation to get science ideas they need

02:19:20
needed

02:19:45
Collection link: https://learningcenter.nsta.org/mylibrary/collection.aspx?id=RysMO9N9i8M_E

02:20:26
A lot of UDL principles and scaffolding for diverse learners and EL students!

02:20:38
Will the links in the chat be made available

02:20:38
How can this be used in an online classroom?

02:20:40
Thank you for everything!

02:20:43
thank you so much

02:20:46
Thank you so much

02:20:57
Thank you everyone- that was great.

02:20:58
Thank you for your time.

02:21:02
Very worthwhile!

02:21:07
Yes, good question.. How can we use this in an online setting with the move to "At Home Learning"

02:21:08
Thank you!

02:21:11
Thank you

02:21:12
Thank you Trisha and Kate

02:21:14
Thankyou!

02:21:15
Thank you. It was quite informative

02:21:15
Collection: https://learningcenter.nsta.org/mylibrary/collection.aspx?id=RysMO9N9i8M_E

02:21:18
Thank you, that was fantastic!!

02:21:23
Once again, Tricia and Kate, Thank you!

02:21:54
Thank you Trisha and Kate. Very informative and useful

02:21:58
Thank you so much for this! Can we get a certificate of participation for this webinar?

02:22:32
April 22nd is not listed

02:22:35
Thank you

02:22:41
Thank you!

02:22:42
Thank you